The missing ingredient in the movie “Carnage”By
I saw a screening of Carnage the other day. Although the acting was good (especially Christoph Waltz, with a faultless American accent), there is one major ingredient missing.
Twelve Angry Men and Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf, two films to which it has been compared, had it.
By that I mean a reason why these people have to stay together. In the case of Twelve Angry Men, the members of the jury couldn’t leave until they reached a verdict.
In the case of Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf it was the codependency of George and Martha–as much as they hated each other they also counted on their partner’s hatred to energize them.
In the case of Carnage, what keeps the visiting couple from leaving a situation from which any sane person would flee? An offer of more tea.
What could have fixed this? Well, having recently stayed in a New York hotel where at least one of the elevators seemed to be perpetually breaking down, that might have been a suitable device. Yes, the audience would have recognized it as a device but that’s preferable to having them think at least three times that of course the visiting couple would now get the hell out of this situation.